The Tactical Hunter Project (Part 1: The Challenge)

A little bit of a disclaimer, this project got started several years ago. At that point in time there were few, if any, companies building AR pattern rifles for hunting. A few folks, mostly hog hunters, were doing it but it was definitely the exception rather than the rule. Today, everyone from Ruger to Savage to traditional AR manufacturers like DPMS are building and marketing AR pattern rifles for hunting. From starting off ahead of the curve, I ended up way behind it. Nevertheless I have finally completed this effort and wanted to share my journey.

Like all good projects this one started out around the campfire…

I spend a fair amount of time (although not as much as I should) practicing with my home defense rifle. I spend another good chunk of time (although not as much as I should) practicing with my hunting rifle. My home defense rifle of choice is an AR. I could do an entire post (and probably should) on why I chose this platform but for hunting I have always used a lever-action. The campfire discussion posed the question, wouldn’t if be cool if I could use the same rifle for both hunting and self-defense? By combining them, it would effectively double the amount of practice for hunting and home defense without spending any more time money at the range.

The idea was amazingly simple, a single rifle that could serve as a hunting rifle and home defense gun. That way all the practice at the range for deer and hog hunting would translate directly into more proficiency for home defense. It would mean one caliber for both functions, simplifying ammunition supply. Plus, military-style rifles are built tough and can take being knocked around in the woods and you don’t have to worry about marring the fine wood or pretty finish.

From a hunting perspective, the rifle would need to be able to quickly and easily to transition between a brush gun and scoped rifle for 100-150 yard shots. It needed to be relatively light weight. It would need to have enough “stopping power” for humane kills on deer-sized game and the ammo needed to be readily available.

For a home defense perspective, it would still need to be light weight. It should be able to hold a reasonable amount of ammunition. While “stopping power” was still a requirement, I live in a suburban area and over-penetration is a major concern. Ammunition availability was still a concern as was cost. If I were to be able to stock a reasonable number of rounds on hand it would need to be relatively inexpensive.

As much as I love my leverguns, an AR pattern rifle seemed like the best choice for this project.

I like the ergonomics. It’s a breeze to add accessories like lights (pretty much a necessity when hunting hogs at night) and optics can be customized and swapped as easily as can be. The only concern was the caliber.

Yes, I know many people hunt both hogs and deer with 5.56/.223. And yes, it is legal to hunt with around here (although it isn’t in many states). Plus the whitetails in this part of Texas are rather small compared with some other parts of the country. However, I am a bit of a stickler when it comes to a clean humane kill and I don’t feel comfortable with a borderline round. Not a problem, the AR can come in many different calibers including the (dun, dun, duh!) 300 Blackout.

It seems like every gun rag and website has been busy selling this round as the ammo equivalent of Marilyn Monroe. It’s generally pitched as a semi-auto .30-30 and an excellent hunting round, within certain distance limits. Based on my research, I have a few issues with this round. It’s not a distance thing. If you’re taking a shot of more than 150 or 200 yards in the pine forests around where I live you’re probably doing something wrong.

Here’s the deal, numbers don’t lie. While the .30-30 and the 300 blackout are both .30 caliber rounds that’s about where the comparison ends. The 300 blackout delivers significantly less energy at shorter distances than the .30-30 (1377 vs. 1902). It is also expensive and hard to find (this was especially true two years ago when I started this project). Before the 300 Blackout fanboys get all worked up and send me hate mail I think it is a very good round for what it was designed for. It just didn’t match up to the criteria I had.

Other popular rounds for the AR had similar chanllenges (for my needs). The 6.5 Grendel is equally scarce around here. The 6.8 SPC seems to be relatively easy to find and not too expensive but it still isn’t a round I could stock in quantity and use for both defense and hunting.

The AR-10 would be fantastic for hunting but not so much for home-defense. Both the price and weight penalties are pretty high as well.

Then I hit me like a bad shot of vodka…how about the 7.62×39?

Ballistics-wise the 7.62×39 slots in between the .300 Blackout and the 6.8 rounds, not quite as potent as I would like but within the ranges I would be shooting, not bad. Ammo is dirt cheap and plentiful although quality hunting ammo isn’t quite that cheap nor easy to find. From a self-defense perspective, over penetration could be an issue but with hollow point ammo that would be less of an issue than with many full blown rifle rounds.

With that decision made I set about building a 7.62×39 AR.

I’ll share more on that in (Part 2).

God bless

Advertisements

9 thoughts on “The Tactical Hunter Project (Part 1: The Challenge)

  1. I have been working through the home defense weapon debate and besides an 870, I have been thinking along the lines of an AR 9mm pistol. I think it would do great for home defense but you definitely highlighted the complete lack of usefulness for anything else. Looking forward to part 2

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I think a 9mm SBR with a suppressor would be an an handy and fun item to have around. I am hoping we get some changes in the national firearms laws so I can do it without jumping through the hoops and mounds of red tape…
      I do not have mounds of experience with them but I am told a 9mm AR pistol has nearly the same recoil as an AR pistol in 5.56. The big difference is in muzzle blast. A lot of ranges wont allow me to shoot my 7.5 inch AR because of the noise and the fireball it produces.At one point, I thought it would make a great home defense tool but I might burn my house down defending it! I will say that even if I missed a home invader with it he would potentially suffer first or second degree burns and the concussion would probably make him think he was hit….
      Thanks for stopping in and God Bless.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. I have been told that the 5.56 needs at least 10.5 inch to be manageable but the 9mm can go down a bit plus you don’t have to worry about going through as many walls with the 9mm. HP 5.56 become fmj when they get drywall stuffed in the end.

        Liked by 1 person

      2. Take a look at theboxoftruth.com (I think that’s the URL. He did a lot of testing on bullet penetration. Some of the results are pretty surprising but as a general rule light and fast penetrates less than heavy and slow.
        I played with CZ Scorpion this week. The weight and balance are good but the controls are very foreign to me. The MPX is very AR like but heavier than many comparable 5.56 ARs. Not that you asked 🙂

        Liked by 1 person

      3. I’ll check it out. I would love to do more of my own testing but I don’t have a good range for that. Good to know about the scorpion. I have watched some mixed reviews so I have been curious. Just not sure about a perfect solution for me right now. I have little ones In the house so I think I have two situations. Wife and kids are secured in which we hold position and wait for the police to come. The 12 gauge is perfect for this. The second issue is unsecured little ones and I need more precision with limited penetration until the kids are secured. This is my gap the is currently handled by the Walther PPS.

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s